Ian’s Blog – Geocells vs. Geogrids In Stabilisation

By March 4, 2025August 21st, 2025NEWS

Hello folks,

I am the Technical Director here at TCS Geotechnics and have almost 40 years of experience within the geotechnical sector. This is my 2nd blog in a monthly series where I intend to cover various geosynthetic and geotechnical-related topics.

I currently chair the BSI technical committee overseeing UK National standards development related to geosynthetics (B553) and I play an active role in the complementary work at the European (CEN) and International (ISO) levels. I will try to provide updates on useful geosynthetic-related standards developments at UK, European, and international levels and also hopefully provide some pragmatic insight into the application of geosynthetics and their significant benefits. All views expressed are mine alone and not those of TCS, the BSI, or any other organisation.

In January’s blog, I highlighted the recent publication of the long-awaited ISO Technical Report TR 18225-5:2025 ‘Design Using Geosynthetics—Stabilisation’ and recommended that geotechnical and civil designers and specifiers get hold of a copy and digest it. I would like to continue that theme by discussing the use of geogrids and geocells in stabilisation and some of the advantages and pitfalls to consider when choosing between the two.

So Geocells vs. Geogrids in Stabilisation: some thoughts to help you decide.

Fill types: In general, stabilisation geogrids are designed to work most efficiently with angular gravel of a suitable size and grading. Whilst typical well-graded roadstone may be ideal, variations outside grading profiles can also function very well, and a great deal of work is being done to demonstrate performance with more varied and seemingly less ideal materials—particularly site-won recycled fills, which clearly bring sustainable benefits.

On the whole, geocells tend to be a little more forgiving with respect to fill type, as the materials are being contained within larger cells and interlocking with geogrid apertures is not required. So whilst a geogrid will work to some lesser extent with sand, the reduction in stabilisation performance with a geocell is likely to be less.

Installation: The rolling out of a stabilisation geogrid and the subsequent placement and compaction of fills is a very simple exercise and—provided suitable compaction protocols are followed—installation of a stabilisation geogrid is pretty difficult to get wrong. The lateral restraint provided by a geogrid is dependent on the interaction (interlock) with the fill materials and with properly compacted suitable fills, the performance of the system is relatively easy to achieve.

Geocells, however, are a little trickier to install and the correct installation is critical to achieving the required performance. This is because the geocell’s stabilisation efficiency and ability to laterally restrain the fills very much depend on each cell being properly filled and compacted such that the walls of the cells are extended to the point where they are providing satisfactory lateral restraint to the fill material within.

The installation of geocells will usually require the geocells to be stretched out and pinned prior to filling and compaction. As compaction progresses and the cells are progressively filled, it may be necessary to reposition the unfilled cells to compensate for the expansion of the earlier filled cells.

This is obviously not difficult but does require a little more attention during installation. You will also usually need to install a separation geotextile beneath your geocell to inhibit any loss of fill material into the substrate below.

Below is a picture from a site I was called to a number of years ago where the contractor said that the geocell ‘wasn’t doing anything.’. I am sure you can see why there was poor performance from lozenge-shaped cells in the picture, which should obviously be tending towards rounded squares if properly filled.

Please note that there was more robust angular aggregate beneath the surface dressing stone and it is not normally recommended that the walls of the cell be exposed and therefore vulnerable to damage at the ground surface. This geocell had obviously not been properly stretched out, filled, and compacted.

Geometry: Usually a stabilisation geogrid installation guideline will ask for at least 150 mm of fill cover prior to compaction. This is generally a precaution to inhibit installation damage of the geogrid. Also, when installing multiple layers of geogrid, the most efficient vertical separation of those geogrids will generally range from 150 mm to approximately 300 mm. Commonly available geocell thicknesses would range from 75mm to 200mm (although 50mm and 300mm are not uncommon).

Clearly this means that for thinner stabilised layers, perhaps for footpaths or lightly trafficked areas (<150mm), geocells may be more suitable. For thicker stabilised layers, multiple layers of both types of product can be used.

The installation of multiple layers of geogrid is obviously pretty simple and quick, as described above. For geocells, the same installation process described above would also apply, although there would generally only need to be a separation geotextile beneath the bottom layer.

Cost: My intention is generally to avoid commercial issues in these blogs but it would be remiss of me not to point out the cost differences between these two types of material. Geocells will typically cost 3 to 5 times more per m² (depending on cell height) than a typical stabilisation geogrid.

Therefore, you could perhaps procure 3 or 4 layers of geogrid for the same price as one layer of geocell. However, as indicated above, there are circumstances related to geometry and fill type that may steer you towards a geocell.

Applications & Specifications: There is a long, successful history of stabilisation geogrid use in the UK and consequently, the majority of stabilisation schemes for trafficked areas and working platforms will contain geogrid specifications.

In more recent years geocells have been specified more often, particularly where there is a desire to keep the stabilised layer as thin as possible. A good example of this would be so-called ‘no dig zones’ for tree root protection, where there is a need to construct a stiff platform above tree roots on a development to inhibit compaction and root damage via trafficking.

These systems generally function well and are convenient and economic because they tend to cover small areas suited to geocell panel sizes.

Be careful: I have been asked on a number of occasions, ‘What load will your geocell take?’ Those of you with even basic geotechnical knowledge will understand that this question is fundamentally flawed and the only correct answer—the one that generally infuriates the customer—is ‘it depends.’. It depends on a number of key factors, including but not limited to the strength of the subgrade, the size and frequency of loading, the type and compaction of the fill and the acceptable surface deformation.

Now perhaps the subgrade strength and the fill type are pretty obvious and everyone would understand that the acceptable deformation on a construction haul road may be much larger than that for an unbound foundation of an asphalt surfaced highway. However, please don’t forget the influence of repeated loading.

Most of these stabilised systems are utilised for trafficked areas of some sort and clearly it matters whether the traffic is cars or HGVs BUT it also matters how many of them will pass during the life of the pavement. Beware of designs of any stabilised system that are based on single loading.

Conclusion: Geogrids and geocells can both be used to construct efficient and robust stabilised systems. Hopefully I have demonstrated that there is a degree of ‘horses for courses’ in selecting the correct solution for your project.

One thing that is generally common to both is that they invariably offer significant sustainable benefits by reducing not only the thicknesses of processed aggregates used, but also thinner construction profiles, which also means less excavation and disposal.

Reductions in aggregate thicknesses of 50% are not uncommon so please consider what that means in terms of reduced quarrying, transport, excavation & disposal.

I hope that this has been helpful.

Share